The Effect Of Stem-Based E-Learning On Students' Higher Order Thinking Skills In Indonesia: A Meta-Analysis
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.55606/ijel.v2i2.72Keywords:
learning influence, Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS), critical thinking skillsAbstract
Many studies have described meta-analysis on the overall effect of e-learning influence in learning. However, there has been no meta-analysis of the overall effect of STEM-based e-learning on Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS). The purpose of this study investigates the effect of STEM-based e-learning on students' critical thinking skills in Indonesia. This type of research is a Systematic Literature Review (SL) and meta-analysis. Data sources came from 10 national and international journals published in 2018-2023. The process of searching for data sources through Google Scholar, ScienceDirect, Wiley, Eric, and Springer. Data analysis used the Hedge formula to calculate effect size with the help of the JSAP application. The findings show that the effect size value (ES = 0.793) is medium. This explains that STEM-based e-learning provides a very high positive impact and is effective in improving students' Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS). Furthermore, HOTS characteristics do not cause heterogeneity in the results of STEM-based e-learning research on students' Higher Order Thinking Skills. The findings suggest that educators should choose STEM-based e-learning as one of the learning models to improve students' Higher Order Thinking skills in Indonesia.
References
Ak, O., Deni, H., & Gen, H. (2022). A Course Content Designed In Accordance With The 5e Teaching Model Within The Scope Of Stem Learning Approach In Environmental Education Course : My Smart Greenhouse. European Journal of Education Studies, 274–295. https://doi.org/10.46827/ejes.v9i4.4263
Akatsuka, Y. (2019). Awareness of Critical Thinking Attitudes and English Speaking Skills : The Effects of Questions. Journal of Pan-Pacific Association of Applied Linguistics, 23(2), 59–84.
ALJASER, A. M. (2019). The Effectiveness Of E-Learning Environment In Developing Academic Achievement And The Attitude. Turkish Online Journal of Distance Education-TOJDE, 20(2), 176–194.
Alsowat, H. (2016). An EFL Flipped Classroom Teaching Model : Effects on English Language Higher-order Thinking Skills , Student Engagement and Satisfaction. Journal of Education and Practice, 7(9), 108–121.
Aurora, A., & Effendi, H. (2019). Pengaruh Penggunaan Media Pembelajaran E-learning terhadap Motivasi Belajar Mahasiswa di Universitas Negeri Padang. JTEV (JURNAL TEKNIK ELEKTRO DAN VOKASIONAL, 05(02), 11–16.
Azfin Gustria, 2*Ahmad Fauzi. (2020). EFEKTIFITAS E-MODUL PEMBELAJARAN FISIKA BERBASIS STEM EDUCATION TERINTEGRASI MATERI Azfin Gustria , Ahmad Fauzi Program Studi Magister Pendidikan Fisika , Universitas Negeri Padang Jurusan Fisika FMIPA , Universitas Negeri Padang * email : ahmadfauzi@fmip. Jurnal Pendidikan Fisika, 9(2), 105–111.
Azid, N., Khuluqo, I. El, Purwanto, S. E., Susanti, E. N., & Info, A. (2022). Higher order thinking skills , school-based assessment and students ’ mathematics achievement : Understanding teachers ’ thoughts. International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education (IJERE), 11(1), 290–302. https://doi.org/10.11591/ijere.v11i1.22030
Baji, F., Azadeh, F., Sabaghinejad, Z., & Zalpour, A. (2022). Determinants of e-learning acceptance amongst Iranian postgraduate students. Journal of Global Education and Research, 6(2), 181–191.
Bakarman, A., & Almezeini, N. (2021). FACTORS INFLUENCING STUDENTS ’ ACCEPTANCE OF E-LEARNING PLATFORMS IN PRIMARY AND SECONDARY SCHOOLS IN SAUDI ARABIA. International Conference E-Learning, 20, 23–33.
Berestova, A., Burdina, G., Lobuteva, L., & Lobuteva, A. (2022). Academic Motivation of University Students and the Factors that Influence it in an E-Learning Environment. The Electronic Journal of E-Learning, 20(2), 201–210.
Binti Hamzah, L. M., & Binti Wan Yusoff, W. M. (2021). A Scoping Review on Implementation of I-Think Maps and Its Effects on Higher Order Thinking Skills in Malaysian Schools. Asian Journal of University Education, 17(2), 169–182. https://doi.org/10.24191/AJUE.V17I2.13386
Bismala, L., Manurung, Y. H., & Siregar, G. (2022). The Impact of E-Learning Quality and Students ’ Self -Efficacy Toward the Satisfaction in the Using of E-Learning. Malaysian Online Journal of Educational Technology, 10(2), 141–150.
Borenstein, M., & Hedges, L. V. (2009). Introduction to Meta-Analysis Introduction.
Çalişir, E. Ç. (2022). Reflections of Metaverse-Based Education on E-Learning. EJERCongress 2022 Conference Proceedings Internet, 103–115.
Caratiquit, K. (2022). Influence of Technical Support on Technology Acceptance Model to Examine the Project PAIR E-Learning System in Distance Learning Modality. Participatory Educational Research (PER), 9(5), 468–485.
Dabiriyan-tehrani, H., & Yamini, S. (2021). Systematic review and meta-analysis of Altruistic and Game-playing love ( Revisión sistemática y meta- análisis del amor Altruista y Lúdico ). Studies in Psychology, 42(1), 1–46. https://doi.org/10.1080/02109395.2020.1857596
Dewi, K. A. I. D., Suarsana, I. M., & Juniantari, M. (2020). Pengaruh E-Learning Berbasis Rumah Belajar Terhadap Kemampuan Berpikir Kritis Matematika Siswa. Wahana Matematika Dan Sains: Jurnal Matematika, Sains, Dan Pembelajarannya, 14(1), 65–77.
Dharma Ferry1*, Tomi Apra Santosa2, D. K. (2019). Pengetahuan Mahasiswa Institut Agama Islam Negeri Kerinci Tentang Teori Asal Usul Manusia Dharma. Bioeduca: Journal of Biology Education, 1(1), 12–17.
Duden Saepuzaman1*, Heri Retnawati2, Edi Istiyono3, H. (2021). Can Innovative Learning Affect Students ’ HOTS Achievements ?: A Meta-Analysis Study. Pegem Journal of Education and Instruction, 11(4), 290–305. https://doi.org/10.47750/pegegog.11.04.28
El-aasar, S. A., & Predictive, G. F. (2022). Predictive Study of the Factors and Challenges Affecting the Usability of E- Learning Platforms in the Light of To cite this article : Predictive Study of the Factors and Challenges Affecting the Usability of E- Learning Platforms in the Light of COVID-19. International Journal of Education in Mathematics, Science, and Technology (IJEMST), 10(3), 568–589.
Elfira, I., & Santosa, T. A. (2023). Literature Study : Utilization of the PjBL Model in Science Education to Improve Creativity and Critical Thinking Skills. Jurnal Penelitian Pendidikan IPA, 9(1), 133–143. https://doi.org/10.29303/jppipa.v9i1.2555
eyide EROĞLU, O. B. (2021). HIGH S CHOOL S TUDENTS ’ V IEWS ON THE 5E- BASED STEM. Acta Didactica Napocensia, 14(2), 203–215. https://doi.org/10.24193/adn.14.2.15
Fadlelmula, F. K. (2022). STEM learning during the COVID-19 pandemic in Qatar : Secondary school students ’ and teachers ’ perspectives. EURASIA Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 18(6), 1–13.
Fadlul Amin Nudin, Rufi’i*, D. A. W. (2021). PENGARUH E-LEARNING, PEMBELAJARAN LANGSUNG, DAN FAKTOR GAYA KOGNITIF TERHADAP HASIL BELAJAR PRAKARYA KEWIRAUSAHAAN. Edcomtech: Jurnal Kajian Teknologi Pendidikan, 6(2), 222–235. https://doi.org/10.17977/um039v6i12021p222
Ferdyan, R., Padang, U. N., Padang, U. N., Padang, U. N., Santosa, T. A., Padang, U. N., Razak, A., & Padang, U. N. (2021). Model Pendidikan Lingkungan Hidup : Kegiatan Pembelajaran pada Siswa Sebagai Bagian dari Lingkungan di Era New Normal. Natural Science: Jurnal Penelitian Bidang IPA Dan Pendidikan IPA, 7(1), 51–61.
Friedensen, R., Lauterbach, A., Kimball, E., & Mwangi, C. G. (2018). Students with High-Incidence Disabilities in STEM : Barriers Encountered in Postsecondary Learning Environments. Journal of Postsecondary Education and Disability, 34(1), 77–90.
Hamad, A. L., Abouelnaga, H. M., & Baz, A. (2022). JOURNAL OF LANGUAGE The Importance Of E-Learning To The Students And Teachers. JOURNAL OF LANGUAGE AND LINGUISTIC STUDIES, 18(2), 952–968.
Hasibuan, M. P., Sari, R. P., & Syahputra, R. A. (2022). Application of Integrated Project-based and STEM-based E-learning Tools to Improve Students ’ Creative T hinking and Self-Regulation Skills. Jurnal Penelitian Pendidikan IPA, 8(1), 51–56. https://doi.org/10.29303/jppipa.v8i1.1050
Hidayah, R. N., & Wiyono, K. (2022). Effectiveness of Using E-learning at STEM-Based Sound-Wave Materials to Improve Collaboration Skills of High School Students. Berkala Ilmiah Pendidikan Fisika, 10(3), 331–341. https://doi.org/10.20527/bipf.v10i3.13850
Hikmah Fitri , Agus Wahyuni, M. (2018). Pengaruh Model Problrm Based Learning (Pbl) Terhadap Kemampuan Penyelesaian Soal-Soal Higher Order Thinking Skills (Hots) Pada Materi Gelombang Bunyi DI SMA NEGERI 1 DARUL IMARAH. Jurnal Ilmiah Mahasiswa (JIM) Pendidikan Fisika, 3(1), 19–23.
Hodiyanto. (2018). PENGARUH MODEL PROBLEM BASED LEARNING TERHADAP HIGHER ORDER THINGKING SKILLS ( HOTS ) MATEMATIS SISWA Hodiyanto. Buana Matematika: Jurnal Ilmiah Matematika Dan Pendidikan Matematika, 8(2), 101–108.
Ibrahim, D. S., Suardiman, S. P., & Yogyakarta, U. N. (2014). THE EFFECTS OF THE USE OF E-LEARNING ON THE LEARNING MOTIVATION ANDACHIEVEMENT IN MATHEMATICS. Jurnal Prima Edukasia, 2, 66–79.
Ikke Pradima Sari, 1 Putri Jannatur Rahmah, 2 Mir’atun Nur Arifah. (2021). PENGARUH E-LEARNING TERHADAP HOTS ( HIGHER ORDER THINKING SKILLS ) MAHASISWA UNIVERSITAS. At-Thullab, 2(2), 455–468.
Kareem, A. (2022). Higher-Order Thinking Skills and Scientific Attitudes Components as Predictors of Scientific Creativity Among Preservice Biology Teachers. International Journal of Progressive Education, 18(4), 0–1. https://doi.org/10.29329/ijpe.2022.459.2
Kim How, R. P. T., Zulnaidi, H., & Rahim, S. S. A. (2022). HOTS in Quadratic Equations: Teaching Style Preferences and Challenges Faced by Malaysian Teachers. European Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 10(1), 15–33. https://doi.org/10.30935/SCIMATH/11382
Kim, N. J., Belland, B. R., & Walker, A. E. (2017). Effectiveness of Computer-Based Scaffolding in the Context of Problem-Based Learning for Stem Education : Bayesian Meta-analysis. Educ Psychol Rev, 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-017-9419-1
Krasodomska, J., Godawska, J., & Krasodomska, J. (2021). E-learning in accounting education : the influence of students ’ characteristics on their engagement and performance characteristics on their engagement and performance. Accounting Education, 4(2), 22–40. https://doi.org/10.1080/09639284.2020.1867874
Kusuma, L. (2020). The Perceptions of Teacher and Student in Senior High School to the Needs of STEM-based E-learning in Physics Learning Process. The 4th ICLIQE (2020), 1–7.
Kusumantara, K. S., Santyadiputra, G. S., Sugihartini, N., Ganesha, U. P., & Digital, S. (2017). PENGARUH E-LEARNING SCHOOLOGY TERHADAP HASIL BELAJAR. Jurnal Pendidikan Teknologi Dan Kejuruan, 14(2), 126–135.
Lee, R., Looi, K. H., Faulkner, M., Neale, L., Lee, R., Looi, K. H., Faulkner, M., & The, L. N. (2020). The moderating influence of environment factors in an extended community of inquiry model of e- learning. Asia Pacific Journal of Education, 00(00), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1080/02188791.2020.1758032
M. Karim , Syafrul Antoni2, Karlini Oktarina3, T. A. S. (2023). The Effect of Teacher Professionalism in Islamic Religious Education in the Era of Society 5.0 in Indonesia: A Meta-Analysis. Jurnal Pendidikan Dan Konseling, 5(2), 1349–1358.
Makhmudah, S., Suyitno, H., & Rusilowati, A. (2021). Mathematics Critical Thinking Ability Reviewing from Gender and Independent Learning Students in Stem Problem-Based Learning Assisted by Web E Learning School. Unnes Journal of Mathematics Education Research, 10(2), 211–219.
Marín, S. L. T., García, F. B., & Vázquez, S. G. (2018). Behaviour & Information Technology A technological acceptance of e-learning tools used in practical and laboratory teaching , according to the European higher education area. Behaviour & Information Technology, 27(6), 37–41. https://doi.org/10.1080/01449290600958965
Mei Ardaning Tyas, Joko Nurkamto, & Sri Marmanto. (2020). Cultivating Students ’ Higher -Order Thinking Skills in Efl Classes : the Role of the Teacher and the. International Online Journal of Education and Teaching (IOJET), 7(1), 267–276.
Milner-bolotin, M., & Marotto, C. C. F. (2018). Parental engagement in children ’ s STEM education . Part I : Meta-analysis of the literature. LUMAT: International Journal on Math, Science and Technology Educatio, 4(3), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.31129/LUMAT.6.1.292
Mufida, S. N., Sigit, D. V., Ristanto, R. H., Education, B., Science, N., & Jakarta, U. N. (2020). ntegrated project-based e-learning with science, technology, engineering, arts, and mathematics (PjBeL-STEAM): its effect on science process skills. Biosfer: Jurnal Pendidikan Biologi, 13(2), 183–200.
Muhammad Syahrul KAHAR1*, Ramadoni SYAHPUTRA2, Rahmatullah Bin ARSYAD3, Nursetiawan NURSETIAWAN4, M. M. (2021). Design of Student Worksheets Oriented to Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) in Physics Learning. Eurasian Journal of Educational Research, 96, 14–29. https://doi.org/10.14689/ejer.2021.96.2
Mujib1, Mardiyah2, S. (2020). Stem : Its Impact To Mathematics Literacy And Stem : Pengaruhnya Terhadap Literasi Matematis Dan Kecerdasan Multiple Intelligence S. Indonesian Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 03(March), 66–73. https://doi.org/10.24042/ijsme.v3i1.5448
N.MURTHY, C. S. H. (2008). Designing E-Learning Programs For Rural Social Transformation And Poverty Reduction. Turkish Online Journal of Distance Education-TOJDE, 9(1), 169–179.
Nisa, L. C. (2012). Pengaruh Pembelajaran E-Learning Kuliah Statistics Mahasiswa Tadris Iain Walisongo Mata kuliah Statistics. Jurnal PHENOMENO, 2(1), 7–27.
Noor, M. E., Hardyanto, W., & Wibawanto, H. (2017). Penggunaan E-Learning dalam Pembelajaran Berbasis Proyek di SMA Negeri 1 Jepara Abstrak. Nnovative Journal of Curriculum and Educational Technology, 6(1), 17–26.
Nuryatin et al. (2022). Effectiveness of Online Learning at Universities: Do Sociocultural Differences Matte. European Journal of Educational Research, 11(4), 2153–2166.
Oktarina, K., Suhaimi, S., Santosa, T. A., & ... (2021). Meta-Analysis: The Effectiveness of Using Blended Learning on Multiple Intelligences and Student Character Education During the Covid-19 Period. … Journal of Education …, 4(3), 184–192. http://journal.ummat.ac.id/index.php/IJECA/article/view/5505%0Ahttps://journal.ummat.ac.id/index.php/IJECA/article/download/5505/pdf
Putranta, H., Setiyatna, H., Choiriyah, S., & Brams, W. S. (2021). The Effect of Smartphone Usage Intensity on High School Students ’ Higher Order Thinking Skills in Physics Learning. Journal of Turkish Science Education, 18(3), 421–438.
R R Musna1, *, D. J. 1 and A. J. (2021). A meta-analysis study of the effect of Problem- Based Learning model on students ’ mathematical problem solving skills A meta-analysis study of the effect of Problem-Based Learning model on students ’ mathematical problem solving skills. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/1882/1/012090
Rahman, A. (2023). Meta-Analisis : Pengaruh Pendekatan STEM Berbasis Etnosains Terhadap Kemampuan Pemecahan Masalah Dan Berpikir Kreatif Siswa. Jurnal Pendidikan dan Konseling. 3(2). 2111–2125.
Rahman, A., Santosa, T. A., Suharyat, Y., & Aprilisia, S. (2023). The Effectiveness of AI Based Blended Learning on Student Scientific Literacy : LITERACY : International Scientific Journals Of Social, Education and Humaniora, 2(1), 141–150.
Razak, A., Santosa, T. A., Lufri, & Zulyusri. (2021). Meta-Analisis: Pengaruh HOTS (Higher Order Thinking Skill) terhadap Kemampuan Literasi Sains dan Lesson Study Siswa pada Materi Ekologi dan Lingkungan pada Masa Pandemi Covid-19. Bioedusiana: Jurnal Pendidikan Biologi, 6(1), 79–87.
Rintayati et al. (2021). Development of Two-Tier Multiple Choice Test to Assess Indonesian Elementary Students ’ Higher-Order Thinking Skills. International Journal of Instruction, 14(1), 555–566.
Riyanti. (2020). Efektivitas Penggunaan Perangkat Pembelajaran Project Based Learning (PjBL) Terintegrasi STEM Berbasis E-Learning Untuk meningkatkan Kemampuan Berpikir Kreatif. DWIJA CENDEKIA :Jurnal Riset Pedagogik, 4(2), 206–215.
Royan Nurochman1, D., & 1. (2022). Pengaruh Penerapan Model Pembelajaran Problem Based Learning ( Pbl ) Dengan Pendekatan Blended Learning Terhadap Higher Order Thinking Skill ( HOTS ) SISWA. Journal of Natural Science Learning, 01(01), 61–67.
Saleem, M., Kamarudin, S., Shoaib, H. M., & Saleem, M. (2021). Influence of augmented reality app on intention towards e-learning amidst COVID-19 pandemic. Interactive Learning Environments, 0(0), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1080/10494820.2021.1919147
Santosa, T. A. (2021). Journal of Digital Learning and Education Meta-Analisis : Pengaruh Bahan Ajar Berbasis Pendekatan STEM Pada Pembelajaran Ekologi. Journal of Digital Learning and Education, 01(1), 1–9. https://doi.org/10.52562/jdle.v1i01.24
Santosa, T. A., Sepriyani, E. M., & Razak, A. (2021). Analisis E-Learning Dalam Pembelajaran Evolusi Mahasiswa Pendidikan Biologi Selama Pandemi Covid-19. Jurnal Edumaspul, 5(1), 66–70.
Saraç, H. (2018). The Effect of Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics-STEM Educational Practices on Students’ Learning Outcomes: A Meta-Analysis Study. Turkish Online Journal of Educational Technology - TOJET, 17(2), 125–142.
Shanti, M. R. S., Istiyono, E., & Munadi, S. (2022). The effectiveness of learning to improve students’ higher-order thinking skills. Cypriot Journal of Educational Sciences, 17(5), 1576–1587. https://doi.org/10.18844/cjes.v17i5.7220
Sigit, D. V. (2022). Integration of Project-Based E-Learning with STEAM : An Innovative Solution to Learn Ecological Concept. International Journal of Instruction, 15(3), 23–40.
Sofianora, A., Suharyat, Y., & Santosa, T. A. (2023). Pengaruh Profesionalitas Guru Matematika Dalam Meningkatkan Kompetensi Siswa Era Revolusi Industri 5 . 0 Di Indonesia : Sebuah Meta-Analisis. 10(2).
Suharyat, Y., Ichsan, Satria, E., Santosa, T. A., & Amalia, K. N. (2022). Meta-Analisis Penerapan Model Pembelajaran Problem Based Learning Untuk Meningkatkan Ketrampilan Abad-21 Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran IPA. Jurnal Pendidikan Dan Konseling, 4(5), 5081–5088.
Suharyat, Y., Santosa, T. A., & Satria, E. (2023). The Effectiveness of STEM-Based Learning in Teaching 21 st Century Skills in Generation Z Student in Science Learning : A. Jurnal Penelitian Pendidikan IPA, 9(1), 160–166. https://doi.org/10.29303/jppipa.v9i1.2517
Suprapto, E., Sumiharsono, R., & Ramadhan, S. (2020). The Analysis of Instrument Quality to Measure the Students ’ Higher Order Thinking Skill in Physics Learning. Journal of TURKISH SCIENCE EDUCATION, 17(4), 520–527. https://doi.org/10.36681/tused.2020.42
Supriyadi, A., Suharyat, Y., Santosa, T. A., & Sofianora, A. (2023). The Effectiveness of STEM-Integrated Blended Learning on Indonesia Student Scientific Literacy : A Meta-analysis. International Journal of Education and Literature (IJEL), 2(1), 41–48.
Sury, K., Wiyono, K., & Siahaan, S. M. (2020). Effectiveness of Using E-learning at STEM-based Physics Learning to Improve Communication Skills of High School Students. Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Fisika, 6(2), 539–548.
Syafryadin, Eka Chandra Wardhana, D., Noermanzah, Agus, R., & Awaluddin. (2022). Students’ perspective and problems in implementing higher order thinking skill (HOTS) in speaking for presentation class. Journal of Language and Linguistic Studies, 18(1), 477–487. https://doi.org/10.52462/jlls.196
Takiddin et al. (2020). Improving Higher Order Thinking Skills Through Probject Based Learning in Primary Schools. TARBIYA: Journal of Education in Muslim Society, 7(1), 16–28.
Tsaparlis, G. (2020). Higher and lower-order thinking skills: The case of chemistry revisited. Journal of Baltic Science Education, 19(3), 467–483. https://doi.org/10.33225/jbse/20.19.467
uparman1*, Yohannes1, N. A. (2021). Enhancing mathematical problem-solving skills of indonesian junior high school students through problem-based learning : A systematic review and meta-analysis. Al-Jabar: Jurnal Pendidikan Matematika, 12(1), 1–16.
Wardani, N. E., Kurwidaria, F., & Supriyadi, F. (2020). Higher Order Thinking Skills dalam Pembelajaran Bahasa dan Sastra Indonesia di Sekolah Menengah Pertama Kota Madiun. Lingua Didaktika: Jurnal Bahasa Dan Pembelajaran Bahasa, 14(1), 29. https://doi.org/10.24036/ld.v14i1.108330
Widyaningsih, S. W. (2021). The Development of the HOTS Test of Physics Based on Modern Test Theory : Question Modeling through E-learning of Moodle LMS. International Journal of Instruction, 14(4), 51–68.
Wijayanto, T., Supriadi, B., & Nuraini, L. (2015). PENGARUH MODEL PEMBELAJARAN PROJECT BASED LEARNING DENGAN PENDEKATAN STEM TERHADAP. Jurnal Pembelajaran Fisika, 9(3), 113–120.
Wiyono, K., Sury, K., Hidayah, R. N., & Nazhifah, N. (2022). STEM-based E-learning : Implementation and Effect on Communication and Collaboration Skills on Wave Topic. JPPPF (Jurnal Penelitian Dan Pengembangan Pendidikan Fisika), 8(2), 259–270.
Yaniawati, R. P. (2012). PENGARUH E-LEARNING UNTUK MENINGKATKAN DAYA MATEMATIK MAHASISWA. Cakrawala Pendidikan, 31(3), 381–393.
Yunita, Y., Juandi, D., Nurhidayah, I. J., Wibowo, F. C., Astra, I. M., Diana, N., & Sukma, Y. (2020). Improving Higher Order Thinking Skills ( HOTS ) with Project Based Learning ( PjBL ) Model Assisted by Geogebra Improving Higher Order Thinking Skills ( HOTS ) with Project Based Learning ( PjBL ) Model Assisted by Geogebra. IOP Conf. Series: Journal of Physics: Conf. Series, 1467, 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/1467/1/012027
Zeng, Z., Yao, J., Gu, H., & Przybylski, R. (2021). Education on Students ’ Abilities. 1, 1–18. https://doi.org/10.15354/sief.18.re005
Zulkifli Zulkifli, Agus Supriyadi, Erwinsyah Satria, & Tomi Apra Santosa. (2022). Meta-analysis: The Effectiveness of the Integrated STEM Technology Pedagogical Content Knowledge Learning Model on the 21st Century Skills of High School Students in the Science Department. Psychology, Evaluation, and Technology in Educational Research, 1(2), 68–76. https://doi.org/10.55606/ijel.v1i2.32
Zulyusri1, Desy2, Tomi Apra Santosa3, S. Y. (2022). Meta-analysis The Effect of the Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK) Model Through Online Learning Meta-analysis The Effect of the Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK) Model Through Online Learning on Biology Learning Outcome. International Journal of Progressive Sciences and Technologies (IJPSAT) ISSN: 2509-0119., 34(2), 285–294.
